Suitcase of Stars by Baccalario Pierdomenico

The English translation of this children’s fiction novel is due out in March of 2014. I was lucky enough to get a (free) digital copy in advance through NetGalley, in exchange for fair and honest feedback. It’s a fun, quick read.

Suitcase of Stars tells the story of how Finley comes to meet the Lily Family, and the story of the Enchanted Emporium. The emporium is a store full of magical items, and ownership of the store has been rotating between seven families for centuries.

Finley and his dog Patches make quite the pair in this fun, magical adventure story. The writing is solid and the main characters are fairly well done. I would have liked to learn more about Ailby Lily and her father. I feel like there could possibly be enough material about them to make a sequel. Finley gets the most attention, almost too much, with the beginning of the book being a little slow. It picks up at the end though!

My only complaint about the novel is that it’s billed, somewhat, as a mystery novel.  In that regard, I feel it’s a let down. To be honest, Finley saves the day at the end, but from who and why? There’s some parts that just don’t add up at the end. What was the involvement of Mr. Everett? Why was Unther Farla there? Is the reader supposed to link the two based on Everett’s mention of being asked to assist as an interpreter?

All in all, this was very enjoyable to read, and I would certainly read more if there were a sequel or series with these characters in the future.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

book review: A Wrinkle in Time

A Wrinkle in Time by Madeleine L’Engle
My rating:  4 / 5

“It was a dark and stormy night.”  Truly a classic opening line for a novel!

Somehow, I missed reading this growing up.  Featuring a female main character, Meg Murry, this is a story about family, about relationships and love, and about good versus evil.

Interested more in math than how she fits in, Meg Murry doesn’t have a lot of friends.  Or maybe any.  She is very close to her younger brother, Charles Wallace, who is quite gifted (imagine a 5-year-old who speaks like an adult).

Together, Meg and Charles Wallace go on an adventure to find their father, who has missing for quite some time.  Meg and Charles Wallace travel through space and time to battle forces of evil.

What I loved about this novel was the mix of an atypical main character (female, “ordinary”, likes math and science) with science fiction and fantasy elements.  It was also refreshing to see a complexly drawn teenage character in a children’s book.  Meg has moments where is she brave and strong, yet she also doubts herself in a real, tangible, relatable away.  It reminds me that no one is just one thing, and that it’s ok to have doubts.  It’s what you do about those doubts that defines who you are, not the fact that you have them.

Now, on to the bad.  I didn’t find the writing to be particularly great, and in parts, I thought it was sort of clunky.  I don’t know if I’m just being picky, or what, but I felt that the writing and some of the writer’s choices (like the names of the supernatural beings who help them on their quest through space and time) really detracted from the story, rather than added to it.

There are a lot of reviews that criticize the religious overtones of this novel.  One reviewer on goodreads.com commented that L’Engle was even more of a religious writer than C.S. Lewis.  To be honest, I didn’t even notice.  When I read The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe as a child, I had no notion of the religious tones of the whole series.  Reading those later, as an adult, I found it oppressive and heavy-handed.  I did not feel that way with A Wrinkle in Time.

Overall, it was enjoyable to read.  If you haven’t read it, and enjoy children’s literature, give it a try!